Wednesday, November 9, 2011

Cheap Soap

The short explanatory note before Cather's "From The Novel Demeuble" introduces the essay well without skipping a beat. The whole time I read this excerpt, I felt like I was looking at a Mondrian painting from 1940, that painted and outlined the meaning of Modernism.

Cather is clearly a modernist writer in the way that she argues "the higher processes of art." She utilizes Hawthorne's The Scarlet Letter as an example of what happens when creativity is taken out of literary art. She argues that it tells you who and what, but it does not allow you to imagine, and it certainly does not allow you to feel.

She says that "whatever is felt upon the page without being specifically named there--that, one might say, is created." She compares novels like these that are more focused on entertaining large quantities to cheap soap, cheap perfume and cheap furniture. This, again, is a perfect example of the Modernist movement.

But if this is the case, and true art is nothing more than this vague "surrounding in the dusk" that leaves the reader to decide whether it falls into the category of creative or not, then everything is relative and subjective. There would no longer be ways to measure and critique art in any way. At what point can you decide a piece of literature is garbage (or rubbish) if you are living on the standard of relativity.

Call me conservative, but I feel as if Cather is sliding too much in the direction of art becoming nothing more than what the next person on the street defines it as, and as a result, it loses its stamina, its skill and eventually its creativity. Art should not be so limited to where there is no room for flying cars or talking lions, but it should not be so relative that there is no formal way to study it and be able to argue its worth.

No offense to Cather, but I think I'll keep my furniture.

Monday, November 7, 2011

"Not to undermine the consequence, but you are not what you do..."

I feel a bit guilty as a sit down to write this because I'm noticing that everyone thus far has written on Moore as well. But after a short-lived internal debate, I find I just can't pull myself away from Moore's "What are Years?"

It may have something to do with the fact that I/we am/are at the age where questions such as those posed in this poem are becoming more and more important... so it should also come as no surprise that I'm kind of at a loss for what to do with it.

What is our innocence,
what is our guilt? All are
naked, none is safe...

This is something that's been on my mind for a while, actually - mostly because I've just come to realize how much I dislike the phrase, "No regrets": "I regret nothing; I have no regrets; I don't regret a minute of it!" My automatic response is, "Then who in the world are you?"

I think I know what most people mean, or are trying to mean, when they say things like that - they want to convey that they are who they are, they wouldn't change anything and they're happy with themselves. Terrific - but I would also hope that there's a healthy amount of regret in there.

The dictionary definition of regret is: "to feel sorrow or remorse for (an act, fault, disappointment); to think of with a sense of loss." It strikes me that regret is, more often than not, a feeling of warranted sorrow. It certainly seems that true repentance for the Christian doesn't come about without a certain amount of regret. "You are not what you do," as Jars of Clay puts it, but that lyric also says "Not to undermine the consequence" - we're not defined by our failures and shortcomings, but we're not far from them either.

This is why I question anyone who claims to be innocent along with anyone who claims to have no regrets, just as Moore seems to do - "All are naked, none is safe." There is a disparity here that should not be denied, she says.

It's interesting that, from there, she would say "whence" is courage, rather than ask "what" it is as she did with joy and guilt. "Whence": where does it come from? She doesn't ask for a definition; perhaps it's assumed we know what it is, but if we need to have innocence and guilt explained to us, it's unlikely that we know what courage is. So it's not exactly a "thing", it's more of a force - it's kinetic. Courage is an "unanswered question," standing up even in the face of hopelessness - it's in process, constantly moving.

To what end, though? Moore seems to suggest that courage is its own end, especially in the face of certain defeat. The body of the poem certainly seems to suggest an objective futility ("Imprisonment rises...struggling to be free and unable to be...this is mortality, this is eternity), but also that "Satisfaction is a lowly thing, how pure a thing is joy."

Is the joy, then, in the struggle itself? Does the joy cease if the object of the struggle is attained? Does the search, even the fight, for meaning become meaningless if we find meaning? Satisfaction, she suggests, leads to complacency - it causes us to stop fighting, and it's in the struggle that we find our real joy. As Eliot valued stillness in "Burnt Norton," Moore seems to see perpetual motion as the ultimate source of happiness.

And the harder I look, the more I find myself disagreeing. And the more I disagree, the more I appreciate. Perpetual motion, at this point in my life, is the only thing keeping me sane in many ways. The struggle keeps me alive, there's always something new to accomplish, it's the fight that gives me the momentum to move forward. But Moore seems to suggest that if you stop to consider the meaning of the struggle, then it only serves to wreck your cadence...

But she misses the meaning of fighting, I think: "To contend in any manner; strive vigorously for or against something." The point of fighting is the removal of an obstruction.

The only reason anyone fights is for the chance to rest at the end of it.

"Blessed be the Lord, that has given Rest unto His people, according to all that He promised. There has not failed one word of all His good promise, which He promised." (1 Kings 8:56.)

Moore is right, there is a purpose in struggle and in questioning and even in "the unanswered question" - but as for me, it's that final victory and everything that comes with it, regrets and consequences and graces and all, that I'm looking forward to.

Sunday, November 6, 2011

A Place for the Genuine

I read The Paper Nautilus first. The title caught my eye because nautili fascinate me and I am rather fond of Jules Verne. This poem has nothing to do with the main portion of my blog post, since it was not assigned in the syllabus. I mention it only to illustrate that Marianne Moore, for me, inspires a broader exploration of her poetry than is required by the class assignments. Her poetry is just what she says it ought to be:

“the raw material of poetry in

all its rawness and

that which is on the other hand

genuine,”

and as she concludes, I am interested. Moore’s poetry examines the “phenomena” of life, such as mortality and the human mind, in a manner both skillful and intelligible that helps the contemptuous reader see “beyond all this fiddle” and into the heart of what is genuine.

In What Are Years?, Moore ponders the topic of mortality. She questions the nature of guilt and innocence, and the place courage occupies in humanity.

“He sees deep and is glad,
Who accedes to mortality,”

she decides, but this is not a morbid fixation on the inevitability of death. In the next line, the thought continues:

“and in his imprisonment rises

upon himself as

the sea in a chasm…

So he who strongly feels,

behaves.”

Moore is advocating the acceptance of death as an earthly boundary, in contrast to the denial of death, or to an attitude of despondency. Death will come, the bars of the cage exist, and the sea cannot escape the chasm. However, the existence of these boundaries does not negate the responsibility of birds, oceans, and mankind to act in the way they were designed to act.

We, as humans, cannot truly live if we attempt to deny death, or if we allow death to stand as a conqueror over us. The bars of the cage, the presence of death, cannot truthfully be described as satisfying, but joy is just as real as death, and can be found in the midst of death. We must acknowledge death and its limited power without despairing. Our own “mighty singing” in the face of death is an affirmation of life, of the existence of both mortality and eternity.

Moore reflects on the human mind in The Mind Is an Enchanting Thing. In the course of the 36-line poem, she compares the mind to, among other things, an insect’s wing, a falling gyroscope, and the compositions of Domenico Scarlatti (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8iw46wMNhWo). The comparisons Moore makes address the swiftly moving functions of the brain—flickers of thought like inconsistencies in sonatas and the brief “fire in the dove-neck’s iridescence.” The mind is also compared to an awl, a sharp tool often used for boring holes in leather, and as an agent that tears mist and veil from the heart. So to Moore, not only does the mind flicker quickly from thing to thing, it also has the ability to penetrate and stir the heart.

Moore claims that the mind exists in order and “unconfusion,” despite its rapid and confused function. The order of the mind comes from its pattern of interconnection like the katydid’s wing and from its own “conscientious inconsistency.” Thus, even in the seemingly disorganized working of the human mind, Moore emphasizes the form that exists, in the mind’s consistency of changefulness.

Marianne Moore wrote for understanding, of

“hands that can grasp, eyes

that can dilate, hair that can rise

if it must,”

of common “phenomena,” baseball, kiwi birds, and things that unite humanity. She wrote openly of death and difficult questions. Her poetry displays both complex patterns of rhyme and of life that, while not always obvious, are well worth discovering.


As one English student to another, the rest of Moore's poems in the anthology are more than worth the time it takes to read them.

I want some more of Moore

Marianne Moore is a breath of fresh air. Her style and poetry meets the reader in a genuine and thoughtful way. Her work "Poetry" begins by frankly stating "I, too, dislike it" referring to the very thing she has devoted her life to. Ironically, for me this allowed a feeling of relief: the poet herself understands me and my frustration over the difficulty in understanding poetry! She breaks the ice and finds common ground where all can stand on. However, she doesn't end here. She states that by having a "perfect contempt" for poetry offers, in fact, a place for genuine understanding.

Clearly, Moore is in a tizzy over the haughty interpretations critics approach poetry. When they attempt to intellectualize poetry down to its core, their response becomes "unintelligble." Because we cannot admire what we do not understand, we mare its significance and its beauty for what it is.

To describe the beauty in peculiar things, she offers allusions to nature--a bat resting upside down, an elephant pushing, a tireless wolf under a tree. In the middle of these descriptions, she cleverly puts in "the immovable critic twitching his skin like a horse that feels a flea." Putting this in is comical, because the first image that came into my head when reading this line was that of an animal. I instinctively read "critic" as "critter." Perhaps, she is mocking the "high society" class of criticism in poetry?

She calls poets that aim too high in their craft, "half poets." What must happen for a "half poet" to become whole is to take on the "literalists of the imagination." Imagination, then, is key to all poetry. Her phrase "imaginary gardens with real toads in them" is a catchy phrase and a fun image. Moore finishes her poem with saying that one is interested in poetry if one demand's that there be both rawness and genuine qualities.

I think Moore is saying that the imagination is the root of all rawness and ingenuity. The imagination cannot be contrived or perceived as anything but your own mind. The imagination is what brings poetry to life. When critics try to force imagination out of poetry, they kill the very art of poetry itself.

Similarly, in her poem "The Mind is an Enchanting Thing" describes the ethereal quality of the human imagination and intellect. It helped me to put the poem into a bullet point:

The Mind is an Enchanting Thing like...
1) the glaze on a katydid-wing
2) Gieseking playing Scarlatti
3) apteryx-awl

The mind is an enchanting thing that...
1) has memory's ear
2) has the power of strong enchantment
3) tears the veil

The first three examples are certainly "enchanting" things --a hero of Greek myth, a Classical Greek, and a flightless New Zealand bird. On top of these words' actual meaning, I believe she picked these three things because they are unique words and had particularly interesting pronunciations and articulations.

Near the end of the poem, she says that the mind "tears off the veil." This could very well be an allusion to Jesus' death where the veil tore in two. I believe this to be true because the end of her poem relates to the biblical story of Salome and the beheading of John the Baptist. She ends the poem with "it's not a Herod's oath that cannot change." The back story behind Herod is that he made a promise to his step-daughter Salome that he would give her anything she wished...and she chose the head of John the Baptist (sheesh, most daughters would ask for a husband, wouldn't ya think?). Herod gave an oath he couldn't return--unlike what the mind can do. I think what she's trying to get at here is that the mind is not nearly as rigid as a promise. It can move in every which way, having feelings and emotions that alter and vary. It is truly man's greatest tool, but also must be used wisely, as it can vary so that it can go to many extremes.

Moore's poetry is enchanting. She wrote at a particularly telling time in history in the 1920s-1960s where women were gaining prominence in literary circles. She wrote in a unique manner where stanzas were counted by syllables. She was subtle in her approach, but resonates deeply when one takes the time to truly appreciate her work. It is obvious that she does not try to be someone other than herself in her work; the honesty she presents is what makes her so endearing. When you know that a person is truly writing from their soul, that is when you can distinguish between the half poet and the whole.



Thursday, November 3, 2011

Morality & Mockery

I must admit that my initial reading of Wallace Stevens’s “A High-Toned Old Christian Woman” left me completely baffled. The whole about peristyles and masques beyond the planets…strange. Bawdiness “converted into palms, / Squiggling like saxophones”? Even less sense. It was only after reading a few paragraphs of notes about the poem by Daniel Schwarz (critic and professor at Cornell) that things started to fall into place.

In the poem, Schwarz says, Stevens “proposes that religious fictions have no greater status than fictions of the imagination that include sensuality and play.” Schwarz makes further comments, but even that little bit allowed me to see the poem in an entirely new light (or rather, in any light at all instead of my previous dark).

With this new lens of understanding, the first thing I noticed was what must be a play on words: where he “make[s] a nave” of moral law (l. 2). I can’t imagine that this is anything other than a pun on the old word knave, which the Oxford English dictionary variously defines as a boy of “low condition” or even as “an unprincipled man, given to dishonourable and deceitful practices.” Thus, Stevens (or at least the speaker) takes a shot at religion by identifying the nave—the central approach to the altar of a church—with a contemptible and unprincipled person.

The speaker then equates the conscience with palms (an allusion to Christ’s triumphal entry into Jerusalem) or guitars “hankering for hymns.” In other words, it merely does what it is supposed to and isn’t a dynamic entity; it’s merely a part of humanity.

The next section is difficult, and the best I can make of it (and Schwarz’s hints) is that this projected “masque” is a fantasy realm where “our bawdiness” may be “indulged at last”(ll. 8-10). In this realm, morality is not absolute but is what we make it (for lewdness has been “converted into palms,” earlier equated with the conscience)(l. 11). Here, Christians (presumably identified by the “disaffected flagellants,” probably a reference to the monk-ish or Dimmesdale-ish practice of self-flagellation) may as well give way to the “jovial hullabaloo”(ll. 15,20). This succumbing is, according to Schwarz, “a kind of carnival, a release, a pleasure principle.”

Naturally, the widow and Christians like her will cringe at any such proposal as the one the speaker suggests. But that doesn’t matter, because this fantasy universe of hullabaloo cannot be controlled: “fictive things / wink as they will”(l. 21-22). By the very last sentence, it seems that this fictional kingdom will make itself most known when it is most jarring to the widow or Christian. “The more we would deny that aspect of life,” Schwarz interprets, “the more it asserts itself.” Taken in sum, then, “A High-Toned Old Christian Woman” seems to be a sort of frustrated rant toward legalistic Christianity, and sacrilegious seems the most appropriate word for describing its shock value.

Even given this interpretation, it is difficult to know whether or not Stevens means it. He may genuinely hold these opinions, that humanity is slave to their consciences and that other aspects of our being (sensuality, humor, etc.) should be given equal reign to religion. Or, as just mentioned, he may simply find certain Christians or certain aspects of Christianity frustrating, and could be offering the poem as his own type of release by taking one counter-argument to its extreme, simply to get a rise out of the widow, as it were. Either way, it’s certainly a dense piece worthy of careful study.

As a side note, once I figured it out, I liked it.

Reference:
http://www.english.illinois.edu/maps/poets/s_z/stevens/christian.htm

Wednesday, November 2, 2011

"One man's trash is another man's treasure"

Science - State Goal 13: Understand the relationships among science, technology and society in historical and contemporary...

So much depends upon

A red wheelbarrow

Glazed with rain water

Beside the white chickens

“What could possibly depend upon a wheelbarrow? Wheelbarrows aren’t even that useful!” When I first read this poem in high school, these were my thoughts on this work by William Carlos Williams. This poem was assigned to me for a poetry project in my AP English class and I had no idea what I was going to present on so I went searching for answers from my other English teachers.

Because I feel that most people have the same view as I did when they first read this poem, I’d like to share what my teacher, Ms. Scholten, shared with me and the analysis of the symbolism that we did together. (Don't worry Dr. Fruhauff, this is not a "copy and paste an essay from High School" type of thing. I don't even have the essay from high school saved.)

What could possibly depend upon a wheelbarrow? Imagine a farmhouse in which a fatally ill child is confined to bed with one window in the room, overlooking this scene described in the poem.

Beginning with the second line, we see symbols of life. Red is the color of life – blood, when red, contains oxygen which is a necessary part of human life. Red also is a symbol for passion – without passion, life does not feel as if it is worth living. So in this small three letter word, we already see how this poem might have more depth than meets the eye. The wheel of the wheelbarrow represents the circle of life and is a reminder that life continues. In the third line the word glazed also points us to the theme of life. When I think of the word glazed (besides thinking of Kwik Trip donuts) I think of glazed over eyes. Glazed eyes are full of life but in death, eyes are dull, cold and empty. Rain is cleansing, life-giving water –spring brings plants and flowers that come to new life because of the rain. In the last line, the chickens are intentionally described as white because white is the color of purity and new life. The chickens also represent life in a more physical way than the rest of the symbols –they are the one thing that is actually living and breathing in this farmyard scene.

Think back to the farmhouse scene that we discussed earlier –this dying child, who may be running out of the will to live sees this scene outside the window. The child looks at all of these symbols of life –the color red, the wheel, the glaze of rainwater, the color white, and the chickens –and suddenly realizes that life still exists amidst the small confines of his or her space. This scene is an encouragement to the child to keep pursuing life – that life is not over –it still exists abundantly even right there in that small farm yard. This scene gives the child will to keep fighting the disease because life is still worth living.

So even if nothing in our life depends upon red wheelbarrow glazed with rain water beside some white chickens, this scene could mean the world to another person. “One man’s trash is another man’s treasure.” When reading over this poem quickly without thinking of its symbolism or meaning, we might think it is garbage. But if we were that small ill child, we would be treasuring it and holding onto the hope that is written in those 15 short words.

As with any interpretation of something, I can’t be positive that this meaning was the author’s intent but because he starts off with the line “So much depends upon,” I can’t help but think that he meant this poem to be worth so much more than its face value. I hope this description of the symbolism used and the scenario in which something would depend upon this scene helps you to better understand and also enjoy the poem as much as I have since learning about it in high school.

Tuesday, November 1, 2011

Spring and All

“Spring and All” by William Carlos Williams was not just about landscape or nature. It did describe in length the attributes of nature and natures awakening from winter but at the same time it felt like it was describing a moment of rebirth or natural birth.

“They enter the new world naked, cold, uncertain of all save that they enter. All about them the cold, familiar wind” (Williams 1467) and “But now the stark dignity of entrance-Still, the profound change has come upon them: rooted, they grip down and begin to awaken.” (Williams 1467).

Both of these stanzas taken from the poem not only describe the awakening of life after a cold winter but also an awakening or the soul (rebirth). When the reader sees that this poem is meant to be taken metaphorical and not just literally it allows them to relate to the message of the poem. It makes the poem more than just being about spring and instead it is about the growth within the individual and the ability to restart and enter the world with dignity and uncertainty of the future. This is something everyone strives for, especially if they feel they have made mistakes and wish to start over. The idea that the winter, the hard months of frozen fear or stress, is now gone and the chance to grow in the warmth of the healing spring, the time for new choices and new goals is an idea that is appealing to most readers.

In regards to this poem being about natural birth it could be assumed that because William Williams was a doctor, specifically dealing with house calls that occasionally dealt with childbirth, that he was describing the experience he witnessed of a new life coming into the world. The two stanzas mentioned above also reflect that idea of babies entering the world. This was also written during the Depression and that is why there is emphasis in this poem about spring being colder than one would usually describe it. There is an element of birth as a shocking experience, an experience that is scary and uncertain while at the same time it is embracing life.

Restarting always feels like it is impossible with humans because our past has a way of always being present within our lives. But within this poem I get the impression that there is hope for humans. We can restart and grow, like a flower in the spring breaking free from the confines of the frozen tundra. That was the main message that I found within this poem.

As I was researching more about this poet and poem I realized that I tend to not try hard enough to understand the meanings within these poems. Sometimes, yes, I believe that the poems are silly and have no real deep message (for instance in my case “This Is Just to Say” was a great example) but as we were discussing “The Hollow Men” I realized that I enjoyed finding the hidden meaning within the text and it was very interesting to discuss it with others. I took that new knowledge and applied it to this poem and found myself thinking new things about something that on first glance I thought was only about nature. “Spring and All” was in between too simple and too difficult because it was hard at first to find the deeper meaning behind the words but as one of my suite mates read the poem out loud to me things became clearer. A mix of metaphorical and practical meanings soon became apparent to me and this allowed me to organize my thoughts more effectively.